Hey everyone,
I’m a senior at a U.S. high school applying to McGill for both the Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) at Desautels and the Bachelor of Arts (B.A.).
My school strictly uses a raw 100-point numeric scale on our transcripts. We don't have letter grades at all, and our school profile doesn't provide a conversion chart or calculate class rank. My raw average is a 90%, but I have very high course rigor (6 APs, 2 dual enrollment classes, and an IB course) and a 1450 SAT.
I’ve been trying to figure out how McGill is going to evaluate my raw numbers when the self-reporting portal opens, especially for specific prerequisites (like the math requirements for Desautels that ask for a B+ or an A-).
I emailed McGill Enrolment Services and got totally conflicting answers:
First, they sent me a link to the internal McGill university grading catalog (where an 85–100% is an A / 4.0, and a 75–79% is a B+ / 3.3), telling me to convert my high school grades using that as a reference.
When I asked if that meant a 76% in my high school math course would satisfy a B+ prerequisite, a different agent replied and said Undergraduate Admissions actually evaluates high schoolers based "directly on your specific high school's own grading scale for context" (which my school doesn't have).
Obviously, if they used the 85=A scale for high schools, nearly everyone would have a 4.0, which seems unlikely. But if they just chunk grades by 10s (90-100=4.0, 80-89=3.0), it completely erases grades like A- or B+, which makes clearing specific prerequisites mathematically impossible.
For past U.S. applicants who had raw 100-point numeric transcripts without letter grades:
• How did the self-reporting portal actually look for you? Did you type in your raw numbers, or did a dropdown force you to pick a letter grade/scale?
• Does McGill actually use the 85-100 scale on the backend for US high schoolers, or do they apply a standard U.S. scale (where 93+=A, 90-92=A-, 87-89=B+, etc.)?
• Given a 90% raw average but heavy advanced rigor and a 1450 SAT, how do I actually track against the published competitive 4.0 averages for Arts and Commerce?
I've already escalated an email to admissions leadership, but I wanted to see if anyone here has firsthand experience with how the portal treats raw numbers. Thank you!