r/MLBTheShow • • 3d ago

The Dugout The Dugout! ⚾: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow - week of October 23, 2026

2 Upvotes

Welcome to The Dugout! ⚾

The Weekly Free-Talk Thread for r/MLBTheShow

Welcome to The Dugout, your weekly home for questions, gameplay advice, pack pulls, Community Market discussions, and everything else MLB The Show!

The Dugout also serves as a community resource hub, with helpful links to FAQs, technical support, and other useful information.

Please review the guidelines below before creating a dedicated post. Our goal is to encourage meaningful discussion while keeping repetitive and low-effort content in one convenient place.

What qualifies as a dedicated post in r/MLBTheShow?

Dedicated posts should encourage meaningful discussion, share original content, or showcase something noteworthy.

  • Diamond Dynasty: News, strategies, program updates, analysis, and meaningful discussions.
  • Player Cards: New card reveals, detailed reviews, comparisons, and discussions. Please search for existing posts before creating a new one.
  • Gameplay Screenshots and Videos: Interesting gameplay clips, screenshots, and highlights. Please use your console's built-in capture and sharing features only. Photos of television screens may be removed.
  • Franchise, RTTS, and Other Modes: Meaningful discussions, discoveries, guides, and original content.
  • Polls: Include sufficient context to encourage meaningful discussion rather than simple yes-or-no questions.
  • Memes and Humor: Keep content original, tasteful, and relevant to MLB The Show.
  • Appreciation Posts: Share your appreciation for favorite players, developers, memorable experiences, and even Ramone!
  • Significant Achievements: Flawless Battle Royale runs, first-time World Series rankings, exceptional discoveries, Top 50 placements, and other noteworthy accomplishments.

Please search for existing discussions before creating a new post about a recently covered topic.

Please use The Dugout for these types of posts:

  • Community Market and Stubs: Buying, selling, flipping, investments, pricing questions, and stub-making advice.
  • Pack Pulls and Routine Accomplishments: Show off your pulls, rewards, program completions, and everyday achievements.
  • Lineup and Player Advice: Ask for lineup recommendations, squad improvements, and player comparisons. Please include your lineup, available stubs, game mode, and what specifically you're looking to improve.
  • Simple Questions and Gameplay Help: Beginner questions, settings, tutorials, basic troubleshooting, and anything that doesn't warrant a dedicated discussion.
  • Rants and Complaints: Frustrated with an opponent, bad animation, or heartbreaking loss? Share your frustrations here, but keep discussions civil.
  • Custom League Advertisements: Share your league settings, requirements, and joining instructions here. You may also use r/findacustomleague. Standalone league advertisements are not permitted.
  • Finding Opponents and Teammates: Looking for someone to play against or team up with? Connect with other players here.
  • Self-Promotion: Have a blog, YouTube channel, or stream? Active community members may share relevant content here. Repeated promotions, spam, and unsolicited advertising are prohibited.
  • Concept Cards: Share your concepts here and follow the Concept Card Guidelines.
  • Custom Stadiums: Share your creations here or visit our affiliated subreddit, r/mlbtheshowstadiums.
  • Other Casual Discussion: Anything related to MLB The Show that doesn't require its own dedicated post.

A few additional reminders:

Helpful resources to use before posting

  1. Search First: Have you used Reddit Search or tried Google?
  2. Official FAQ: MLB The Show Frequently Asked Questions
  3. Community Resources: Our r/MLBTheShow FAQ and Guide.
  4. PlayStation Network Status: Check for outages HERE.
  5. Discord Community: Join our official r/MLBTheShow Discord.
  6. Technical Support: Visit the Technical and Server Issues Megathread.

Community Guidelines

Please treat other community members respectfully, including those who are new to the game. Disagreements are welcome, but personal attacks, harassment, and intentionally disruptive behavior are not.

These guidelines are not exhaustive and are subject to moderator discretion on a case-by-case basis. If you believe a post or comment requires moderator attention, please use Reddit's report function so the moderation team can review it.

Enjoy the discussion, and welcome to The Dugout! ⚾


r/MLBTheShow • • 4d ago

Comparison Finest Awards 2026 Results: The Cards You Voted For

14 Upvotes

Finest Awards 2026 Results: The Cards You Voted For

Voting closed October 20, so here are the results. Thanks to everyone who posted a top three. Each ballot counts once per card, and only the first three cards named in a comment are counted.

Top of the board

  • Andruw Jones (HOF): 7 votes, tied for first
  • Nick Sogard (Spotlight): 7 votes, tied for first
  • Jesus Made (Pipeline): 6 votes
  • Yordan Alvarez (AS): 4 votes

Tied at 3 votes

  • Cole Carrigg (94 Topps Now)
  • Ozzie Albies (ASG)
  • Ketel Marte (Vintage)
  • Brandon Lowe

Tied at 2 votes

  • Adam Dunn (Moonshot)
  • Cody Bellinger (AS)
  • Jordan Walker (HR Derby)
  • Kyle Schwarber (Field of Dreams / HR Derby)
  • Stan Musial
  • Willie Castro
  • Ken Singleton
  • Victor Martinez (Awards)
  • Max Clark (Pipeline / Breakout)
  • Idelmaro Vargas (Spotlight)
  • Lightning PCA

Also received votes (1 each)

Roberto Clemente, Ted Williams, Corey Seager, Juan Soto, Jackie Robinson, Adley Rutschman, Craig Biggio, Dustin Pedroia, Esteury Ruiz, Jacob Misiorowski, Carlos Santana (WBC), Maikel Garcia, Roman Anthony, Kyle Tucker, Elly De La Cruz, Xavier Edwards, Liam Hicks, Carter Jensen, Brett Bateman, Kazuma Okamoto, Dillon Dingler, Dustin May, Josiah Hartshorn, Junior Caminero, Troy Tulowitzki, Manny Ramirez, TA Leiter, Nasim Nunez, Honus Wagner, Piazza, David Wright, JJ Wetherholt, JJ Bleday, Ali Alonso, Beltran, and others.

Method notes

  • Removed comments were excluded.
  • Unclear or joke picks were excluded, including a Trevor Story joke and a staged list that didn't name clear top-three cards.
  • When a player appeared in two versions on one ballot, each version counted separately.

Thanks to everyone who voted. Results are now enshrined.

Original post where votes were made


r/MLBTheShow • • 8h ago

First Look First Spooky Advent Program announced

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

J.R Richard is in the new program and Willie Mays from the Conquest map, both coming out at Noon PT


r/MLBTheShow • • 5h ago

Discussion SDS has 3,400+ Topps Flashback card arts. What could they do with them?

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

SDS has a large library of Topps Flashback card art, over 3,400. The cards are from specific years and fall into the All-Star, Breakout, Veteran, Standout, Rookie, Second Half, and Last Ride series. No stats are attached to any of them that I can see. They have had this bank as far back as 2022 to my knowledge.

This could be a bank for future games. Only about 4.5% of this art appears in DD this year, so there’s a lot players haven’t seen yet. Some players are redundant.

Mike Trout is a good example, he has over ten cards in the library, seven of them All-Star. You wouldn’t want to release all ten at once, but what if SDS released 3 or 4 Flashbacks per year, each with different attributes and splits?

If SDS released even 15% to 20% of the library each year, players would get a lot of variety per player, and the Topps art would finally get the spotlight it deserves. It could also make standard packs more interesting again. Imagine bronze, silver, and gold Flashback cards regularly mixed into packs, like a second live series running alongside the main one.

What would you want to see them do with these? I personally would like to see a removal of attributes to 125 and go back to 99, and then add a ton more cards and see these replace cards like award series, summer series, etc. This library has over 900 All-Star cards alone, with only 50 in DD this year!


r/MLBTheShow • • 6h ago

Funny Beautiful Video Game

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

18 Upvotes

Up 2, bottom of the ninth, no one on, give up a…..walk off homer? Just fantastic stuff


r/MLBTheShow • • 17h ago

Show Off Got every single Mune P5

Post image
66 Upvotes

Pretty happy with this and my full White Sox P5 Team. Just waiting on my Finest Miguel. Hate that SDS just basically decided Team Captains are no longer a thing. I used my White Sox TC all year last year.


r/MLBTheShow • • 33m ago

Question Pinpoint Fastball Release

• Upvotes

Does anyone else struggle with specifically fastballs when using pinpoint (online ranked)? Every other pitch I can consistently get perfect release with but for some reason I almost never do with fastballs. Using a wired gamesir pro on Xbox. I don’t know what I’m doing wrong.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1h ago

PSA Waiver wire can build pretty decent team

• Upvotes

In case people don't know, especially post spring training and trade deadline when a lot of guys are out od options and teams need to make decision... you can build a very solid roster from this. Got several 80+ overall A and B potential guys between 27-30 with several years before free agency through that.


r/MLBTheShow • • 9h ago

Question 26 Choice Packs saved up

4 Upvotes

I have 19 Deluxe and 7 Premier Choice packs saved up currently. When does the Finest Series drop? It’s my favourite of the year and I want the entire series ASAP.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1h ago

Question Hitting Problems; PS5

• Upvotes

I play on PS5 and I’m very low ranked. I play a decent amount of online but I feel like no matter what I can’t see pitches or do better hitting. Are there any tips anyone can give me to improve on my hitting?


r/MLBTheShow • • 2h ago

Discussion Does anybody else just watch games sometimes, like while you are doing something else? Especially playoff/world series games that your team is not in.

2 Upvotes

I know its not normal and know a majority of people find it boring, but I do it for fairness sake. I usually watch while I do other stuff, but will come back to check the score. I like it, because it feels like its not just random like when you sim a game, it feels more realistic. And it makes for amazing storylines for an alternate reality, since its out of your hands. (I call it "real fantasy baseball" since I use the real rosters, but don't block crazy trades/free agency acquisitions, so it can get wacky lol)

For example, my Guardians lost the 2027 ALCS to the Mariners, who are playing the Braves. The Mariners lost the World Series last year to the Brewers in 6 games. When I simmed the WS 5 times (just to see the results), the Mariners won everytime (in this reality, the Mariners not only landed Bichette, but Caminero as well lol). I felt bad for the Braves a little bit (lost the 2025 NLCS to the Dodgers and the 2026 NLCS to the Brewers) so I decided to watch every game of the World Series. Well, I just watched game 6, Mariners at home up 3-2 in the series after some comebacks in game 2 and game 5. Up 2-1 going into the 8th and they blew the lead. Now a game 7 that I am eager to watch to see if for the second time in MLB (alternate) history an AL West team loses its first 2 World Series back-to-back, and in an eerily similar fashion lol

Well, I will watch it muted while I watch the real World Series on another TV lol


r/MLBTheShow • • 8h ago

Question Easily navigable list of players per organization?

2 Upvotes

Tried the googles and didn't find a quality result. Basically, looking to get a list of players from the Rockies organization before I buy the game. I live in Spokane, WA, home of their high-A affiliate, and would want to start a franchise with players I know and watch. Specifically looking for Jack O'Dowd (future legend) and players like Robert Calaz from the 2026 squad. Thanks!


r/MLBTheShow • • 2h ago

Question Just Purchased A PS5

0 Upvotes

I can't seem to get out of the mode of starting with the Toronto Blue Jays and LA Dodgers. Help?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Funny Do you really need this many first basemen?

Post image
22 Upvotes

Sometimes the AI in drafting is really weird.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

First Look “Spooky” Daily Drops Revealed

Post image
53 Upvotes

“Your opponents might want to look away when these spooky stars step into the box.”


r/MLBTheShow • • 12h ago

Discussion Let's talk out pivoting the Captains model to a more MUT/FUT "Chemistries" setup

0 Upvotes

I was a fan of Captains at inception. Then they got a little too overzealous (when they had to make a new captain every "set"), then they got a little too crazy ("High Durability" Captain), and then they were just straight up abused ("Switch Hitting" Captain). Now they've been scaled back to the point of being negligible at best, and a liability at other times.

With the Postseason programs, I'm sure we all have been carrying a lot of Brewers hitters or Dodgers pitchers, etc etc for a few games at a time. I could have a full lineup 1-9 of Brewers hitters, but don't get a bonus unless I plug in 88 Ted Simmons instead of one of my growing number of red-diamonds. Then we all are faced with doing the mental gymnastics of if bumping a hitting stat from an already astronomical 115 to 121 is worth having a 90con 50pow bat at the end of the lineup.

If SDS doesn't have the bandwith to either provide updated captains, or a way to increase the current captains' attributes, let's just pivot to the "Chemistries" model that other sports games like to use. Let's talk through some of the features you need to see in this model, or would like to see. If SDS hands you the reins tomorrow to develop a Chemistries Model...

  • Are team setups worried about just shear numbers of players on the team, or do positions matter? If your whole infield is Brewers, outfield is Dodgers, and Pitching staff Rays, do they each get a bump based on numbers, or does only the largest segment get one? Can pitchers get bumps for teammates in the field, or batters get bumps for bullpen staff?
  • Are there negative synergies based on rivals? If I have a NYY shortstop trying to turn a double play with a BOS 2nd baseman, is there a negative effect to the catch and/or turnaround time? Would a throw from a Padres OF be inherently off-target to a Dodgers C? On the opposite side, would battery-mates create better pitching stats? Would throws between fielders from the same team get bigger "perfect" sections on the accuracy meter?
  • How do we handle Legends players? Players already get secondary positions, do we dole out secondary team affinities too? It's always weird for me - even as a Phillies fan - to see cards like Jim Thome and Billy Wagner get Phillies cards. Yea, they suited up for my team for a bit, but they are clearly known for playing for other teams. Also, this could help curtail all the "this guy was on the Yankees for a cup of coffee, lets give him a NYY card!" shenanigans we've been seeing so often this game cycle...

Let me know your thoughts. If SDS is going to let the Captains model just rot in the dirt, I think something like this is what they should pivot to, but what are some pitfalls or rostering strategies you would like to see implemented if something like this rolls around? I think this would help make theme teams more fun (especially if chemistries extended to programs cards like boosting a lineup of "ASG" cards or "Pipeline" cards), but could be abused if teams get oversaturated again with a ton of 99's, and you have max chemistry on an already OP lineup.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

PSA cards coming quickly source clyde

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

expect cards within two week for these players source dougs and clyde

randy johnson

george polanco

willy mays

bo bichette

andrew miller

gary sheffield

these posts keep getting removed but they have not been wrong. clyde not missed in forever. dougs legitimate as well

let me know quesition if have any. thanks


r/MLBTheShow • • 8h ago

Discussion Should there be a penalty for console quitting?

0 Upvotes

In ranked just now, just hit a 2 run bomb that would have made it 5-1 in the 5th inning. Before the ball hits the stands, the user powered off their PlayStation. Of course the stats don't count.

But, should there be some sort of cooling off period where a player can't play online if they quit in ranked?

Would be hard to determine that versus a power outage or blip, unless SDS looks at people exiting suddenly then jumping right back in the game.

Thoughts?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Why did SDS introduce shrinkage?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

13 Upvotes

What made them add pci shrinkage into the game? I’ve been told shrinkage wasn’t always a thing until the recent mlbs what was their logic behind putting this mechanic that makes no sense into the game?


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Franchise Had a developing Ethan Holliday to trade away. Trade to the Astros but countered by removing him because of a slight edge?

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

This is mainly so I could make some room for the shortstops but I don’t know why not accepting a young player with good overall and potential was the choice here.


r/MLBTheShow • • 18h ago

Question Why is there still friendly quit bugs

0 Upvotes

I just won a weekend classic game and then all of a sudden it said the game was tied on the scoreboard and then it said the stats don’t count it’s a friendly quit when there was never even an offer.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Question Like how does this happen

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

Yes I use meter , but it said good release and then at the end it says released late , am I doing something wrong besides using meter pitching lmao


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Discussion Is it just me or does

4 Upvotes

Does pitching feel really off this weekend classic or is it just me ? Perfect perfect release and it just doesn’t go there , not the warping glitch but literally perfect pitches not going anywhere near Where the pitch was supposed to go


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Discussion Man I love how the week before weekend classic starts I'm hitting everything on Hof but Mann as soon as that weekend classic starts I can hit one god damn thing.

4 Upvotes

I swear those weekend classic pitch speeds are different.


r/MLBTheShow • • 1d ago

Show Off Finally made WS during the WS

Post image
30 Upvotes

This is my 2nd year playing the game and I finally made WS despite being middle aged with terrible reflexes 🫠 I hate that I care about this but this was HARD, man. So many times I got close. Earned it with a no hitter in the WC too.