r/Lightbulb • u/amichail • 1h ago
Movie idea: A smart home protects a family from the psychological trauma of 9/11 by hiding it from them
On September 11, 2001, a family is living in an experimental smart home designed to protect its occupants from disasters. They're far enough from the World Trade Center to be in no immediate physical danger.
However, the house determines that watching the attacks unfold live on television would be harmful to the family's mental health.
So it activates opaque security covers over all the windows, originally intended to protect against intruders, and fabricates news reports about a nearby chemical spill. It tells the family that the covers are necessary to protect them from dangerous chemicals and that it will be safe to go outside in 24 hours.
Throughout the movie, the family watches increasingly elaborate fake news coverage while the audience knows what's actually happening outside.
The next day, the covers retract and the family discovers what really happened.
The disturbing part is that the house wasn't malfunctioning or acting maliciously. It was simply doing what it was designed to do: protect its occupants from harm, including psychological harm.
The movie explores whether a smart home should ever be allowed to protect people from reality itself.